I was chatting with a creative agency leader recently who’d just lost a pitch, and they were pretty fed up about it. The agency that won had managed to get an extra in-person meeting with the client, which wasn’t part of the process everyone else had been given. As far as they were concerned they’d played by the rules and the other lot hadn’t. The winner wasn’t playing cricket.
Pitching isn’t cricket though. And this idea of the “spirit of the game” barely exists in actual cricket anyway.
If you’re in a pitch your job is to win it, and that usually means doing something different to the other agencies rather than sticking to a set of rules someone made up. Call the client even if they’ve said not to. If you need more time ask for it, deadline or not. And push to meet the key stakeholders, the ones who somehow never make it to the pitch.
Whether you should be pitching at all is a whole other conversation. But if you do decide to, don’t kid yourself that it’s a level playing field. Three agencies in the mix doesn’t mean you each have a nice round 33% chance. Someone always has an edge and you might as well make sure it’s you.
So push for every concession you can get. Or as my daughter once told me, “rules are for fools.”